Divinity and Dawkins Debating Delusions
‘THE DAWKINS LETTERS’
A minister, a Presbyterian minister to boot, with a broad Scottish accent isn’t supposed to take on Richard Dawkins’ ideas in a bookshop like Borders. But this is what happened on January 21st when David Robertson, from Dundee, spoke to an attentive audience of well over a hundred at the Cambridge branch of the shop.
It had such a good response partly of course because Dawkins’ book, The God Delusion, has been a best seller but also because David with his non-religious appearance and style is able to give a credible rebuttal of Dawkins’ rather crude
David was there for a book signing of his own book, The Dawkins Letters, published by Focus, and he explained how originally he had written a critique of Dawkins for his church website which had found its way to Dawkins’ website and had then generated a huge response. This had made him expand his critique into a book. The delight of the evening was to see the confident, articulate and entertaining way David made his case. He answered the mostly critical questions and at the same time challenged us all, Christian and non-Christian alike, to think about the issues.
If more Christian leaders got themselves intellectually up to speed and engaged with secular culture on its own terms and exposed it as David did, it would have a transformative effect. But that would require hard work and the conviction that demonstrating the truth of the gospel is the priority in a culture that justifies its unbelief on the grounds that the gospel is no longer credible.
You can hear David’s talk and Q & A on the Audio page of our website:
By Ian Cooper
AGREEING AND DISAGREEING WITH
DAWKINS Part 1
Even humanists are having problems with Richard Dawkins. He rages against faith but fails to see that faith is no more or less than a set of overarching beliefs with which people make sense of the world’. (1) In this sense humanism is a ‘faith’ like any religion – as humanists themselves are pointing out. Clearly, too, his tirades against religion are excessive and ungracious. Humanists tend to feel as uncomfortable as believers when he appears on the box and their conclusion the same, ‘This man clearly has a chip on his shoulder’. Eminent fellow-scientists find it expedient to distance themselves from his philosophical and ethical meanderings because they realise that amongst philosophers the least said about Dawkins the better. (2) As Christians, therefore, we can allow ourselves a measure of relief as we lament Dawkins’ astronomical book sales. They have made him rich and done harm but a more discerning reaction is at hand even amongst those who share his naturalistic world-view. But we need to go further.
Photo by James UK
First we need to agree that much of his critique of religion is in fact correct. Scripture is if anything more outraged than Dawkins by religious irrationalism and wickedness - something even Christians are in danger of forgetting these days surrounded as we are by political correctness. So we readily echo Sam Harris’ expression: ‘religion poisons everything’. (3) Precisely! That’s just what the Bible says.
The second thing we need to do is to insist that Christianity is not a religion as commonly understood. Theoretically at least and unlike almost all other religious world-views, Christianity claims to be dealing with reality not fantasy. The very territory atheists like Dawkins lay claim to, namely the sphere of science or what we call ‘the real world’, the Bible asserts is declaring the glory of God from day to day.
That religion is the universal problem of all human experience is the common assumption of the whole Bible. Genesis, for example, teaches that all human distress began with a seemingly attractive and plausible religious construct. What appeared to be a move towards a better reality proved to be a move towards un-reality. True religion in short was replaced by false religion. So from Genesis on we trace the history of how all religious myths and inventions emanated from this initial disaster and became increasingly perverse and harmful, even amongst the chosen people of God as they repeatedly turned to idolatry. Jesus shares this repudiation of religion. ‘I am the good shepherd’ he says. ‘All who came before me Photo by Matti Á [from the context clearly meaning religious teachers] are thieves and robbers’. Hence his fierce protest against the religious traditions of the Pharisees. He also says, ‘I am the way, the truth and the life. No man comes to the Father except by me’. To follow other religious leaders is to surrender oneself to the blind being led by the blind.
So we agree with Dawkins that religion does in fact stand at the centre of human depravity and distress, but for different reasons. He protests against religion because he is contemptuous of the supernatural. Only matter exists – period! To him religions are framed by delusion. The Christian views them as a deceipt rather than a delusion because they are false to reality. God’s nature and his attitude towards human beings - his mercy, his justice, his longsuffering – are not accurately represented by other religions. Only that view of reality which he himself has revealed, including his merciful intervention on our behalf in Jesus, adequately represents the way things actually are. So to accept the teaching and worldview of the Bible is to step closer to reality not away from it.
Revealed and directed by the living God the Bible accurately, though not exhaustively, describes the way things really are. It first tells us the truth about how reality is structured and then with equal accuracy explains our need for a divine saviour in history. The structure is true, the history and meaning are true. Human religion, by comparison, is none of these. Therefore it is destructive since human beings, ipso facto, have to live in reality. Only God’s revealed truth sets us free, Jesus says.
Paradoxically such agreement with Dawkins far from simplifying things produces greater and almost overwhelming difficulties for us. Making the assertion that Christianity is in fact ‘reality’ rather than ‘religion’ brings us into conflict not merely with Dawkins and the consensus of our own society, but with the cultural consensus which increasingly spans the globe. What now supplants the absolutes of 20th century tyranny - and ironically western relativism also - is the absolute toleration now demanded of all multi-cultural and multi-faith societies. To assert any single view of reality to be true is to subvert civilised society.
Only one thing compels us to disagree: that the Bible teaches it unequivocally. This brings us to the relevance of Christian heritage, for if Christianity is indeed related to reality its benefits should be identifiable in human history. We believe this to be the case, initially within the history of the Old and New testaments but also within Christian heritage subsequently, good and bad alike, and this we hope to clarify in the next newsletter. Dawkins is right to condemn religion, but he is wrong to overlook Christianity’s uniqueness and truth. He may and must be challenged philosophically and historically.
(1) The New Humanist Nov/Dec 2007 p 16ff.
(2) ‘Now despite the fact that this book is mainly philosophy, Dawkins is not a philosopher (he's a biologist). Even taking this into account, however, much of the philosophy he purveys is at best jejune. You might say that some of his forays into philosophy are at best sophomoric, but that would be unfair to sophomores; the fact is (grade inflation aside), many of his arguments would receive a failing grade in a sophomore philosophy class.’
(3) The subtitle of Sam Harris’ book ‘Letter To A Christian Nation’
The work of Christian Heritage depends on the gifts of friends. Make your
contribution to this pioneering ministry by (UK)
• cheque payable to Christian Heritage , Christian Heritage, Round Church
Vestry, Bridge Street, Cambridge, CB2 1UB
• bank standing order set up either with your on-line bank or by
completing and returning the enclosed form
• Charity voucher to address above
• Our website www.christianheritageuk.org.uk/OurWork/CourseFees&Donations See the link to the Gift Aid form.
• Check payable to Christian Heritage USA Foundation, at
Christian Heritage USA Foundation,
P O Box 11651, Montgomery, AL 36111
• Our website www.christianheritageuk.org.uk/OurWork/CourseFees&Donations
(Author: Ian Cooper and Ranald Macaulay
See feedback for this article
Articles in this group
Why a Christian Perspective on History is Vital
Remember your leaders, those who spoke to you the word of God.
Consider the outcome of their way of life, and imitate their faith. Hebrews 13:7 (Author: Peter Greyling)
Longing for 'Home' in The Hunger Games
November 2012 Article (Author: Angeline Liles)
In what sense does the Bible inform our understanding of ‘goodness’? (Author: Simon Aston)
'A Religion for Atheists?'
A critique of Alan De Botton's book, 'A Religion for Atheists' (Author: Jon Thompson)
Is our history being re-written as we speak? (Author: Kevin Moss)
Western Autumn After 'Arab Spring'?
A fascinating look at recent events in North Africa and the UK. From our annual newsletter, November 2011. (Author: Vishal Mangalwadi)
The End of the World?
It must be testimony to something that Harold Camping has, in so swift a time become a household name and face. The media have gleefully circulated images of this gentleman that entirely support everyone‘s mental picture of the archetypal fundamentalist. (Author: Kevin Moss)
The King James Bible and The Cambridge Connection
The year 1611 marked the authorisation by King James I of England to produce a new Bible in English. 2011 therefore marks the 400th anniversary of the commissioning. (Author: David Berkley)
The Pietistic Roots of Evangelicalism Today
Contemporary Evangelicalism needs to understand and deal with its pietist roots. January 2010 (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
‘By the open statement of the Truth’
Lausanne and the Polemical Imperative (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
The New Atheism
The term The New Atheism is one that Christians have had to get used to in the last few years, even if the ‘new’ connected to atheism seems something of a misnomer. (Author: Ian Cooper)
Francis Schaeffer: A Mind and Heart for God ed. Bruce Little
A book review of the latest book on Schaeffer. which is our book of the month for June. (Author: Rachel Thorpe)
Staying Young Beyond Our Time?
We have long since discarded Shakespeare’s “seven ages”. Instead, we live in a capitalist system which encourages children to grow up as quickly as possible, and then tells adults to stay young for as long as possible. (Author: Rachel Thorpe)
Voting links (Author: Annie Simmonds)
'I'm being taken over': Popular music and the fear of the impersonal
Popular contemporary song lyrics reveal "The Fear" that lies at the core of our culture. (Author: Rachel Thorpe)
'Why I am not a Christian' : a Christian critique
Considering the 'sacred text' of new atheism (Author: Kevin Moss)
Year Round 2008-2009
Recovering the Past, Challenging the Present, Shaping the Future - A review of the last year. (Author: Christopher Townsend)
Don't settle for cheap alternatives
Much has been said and debated recently about the newest craze to hit cyberspace, Twitter. For the uninitiated, (Author: Dom Vincent)
The Roman Return?
The wise keep their eyes on the merits and demerits of ideas for ideas have consequences (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Our Cultured Admirers
People we would expect to be our cultured despisers turn out to be... (Author: Ian Cooper)
Christians and the Credit Crunch
Our TV screens are saturated with the latest reports of... (Author: Kevin Moss)
Belshazzar and the Crash
“Overwhelming pressures are being brought to bear on people who have no absolutes... (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Rescuing Darwin or Wrecking the Faith?
An article published in Evangelicals Now, November 2008 (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
HIS Story Revealed
In a way Christian Heritage is all about stories, so as we near the end of a busy summer season let me share some of them, past and present, to bring you up to date. (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Agreeing and disagreeing with Dawkins Part 2
Ranald argues that nothing in all history surpasses the brutality of the social systems most consistently modelled upon Dawkins' own atheistic world-view – Nazism and Communism. (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
'Education - For God's Sake!!'
A lethal virus has become an epidemic and our children are the victims (Author: Elaine Cooper and Ranald Macaulay)
Dick Keyes on intuition, imagination and knowing God. (Author: Dick Keyes, Photo: karlrpet)
What Can We Learn from Francis Schaeffer?
Ranald Macaulay reflects on the legacy of Francis Schaeffer. (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Truth and Lies
words, truth, and morality (Author: Text: Ranald Macualay, Photo:A@lbi)
Democracy in Iraq?
“Democracy in Iraq? You must be joking!” says the common person today. (Author: Ranald Macaulay, Photo: Chris Christner)
As Implausible as Father Christmas?
Sola Scriptura and Expository Preaching Today (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Humans: Religious by Nature
This claim seems ridiculous to many today who have a sense of the modern secular triumph over superstition, mythology (Author: Dick Keyes)
The UK: Prosperous but Disfunctional?
We are ridiculously prosperous in the UK; (Author: Ian Cooper)
West is East and East is West
On Hinduism and Western Culture (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Wanted: Christian Satirists (GSOH Required)
On Recovering Christian Satire (Author: James Williams)
On Whose Side of the Door is the Handle?
On Whose Side of the Door is the Handle? (Author: Rob Ambler)
Jerry Springer the Opera
Ian Cooper discusses this controversial stage show. (Author: Ian Cooper)
Ideas Have Consequences: Sodom Prophesied and Revisited
The fact that we find ourselves living in Sodom should come as no surprise. (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Paradigms of Tolerance: Cartoons, Compassion and the Cross
Amid the oceans of ink and hours of air-time devoted to the recent ‘cartoons scandal’ (Author: Chris Watkin)
The Dangers of Thin Religion
Francis Schaeffer used to say that what was needed in our time was both revival and reformation. (Author: Dick Keyes)
Religion - A peripheral Issue?
Religion - A peripheral Issue? (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Heaven Knows How We'll Rekindle Our Religion
Heaven Knows How We'll Rekindle Our Religion (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
The Battle of Ideas
The Battle of Ideas (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
The Real Disaster
The Real Disaster (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
The Consequences of Ideas
Yesterday’s paper (1st Dec 2004) carried two fascinating sex-related news items. (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Francis Crick (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Constantine to Charlemagne
Constantine to Charlemagne (Author: Ian Barrs)
Dostoyevsky's 'The Idiot'
Dostoyevsky's 'The Idiot' (Author: Rob Ambler)
The Secular Context and the Christian Worldview
The Secular Context and the Christian Worldview (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Apologetic Communities (Author: Ranald Macaulay)
Evil and Suffering
Evil and Suffering (Author: Jerram Barrs)
Biblical and Cultural Hermeneutics - Christianity and Culture
Biblical and Cultural Hermeneutics - Christianity and Culture (Author: Jerram Barrs)
Epistemology - Philosophy of Knowledge
Epistemology - Philosophy of Knowledge (Author: Jerram Barrs)
Idolatry (Author: Jerram Barrs)
Horatio Nelson (Author: Ranald Macaulay)